Sherni movie review: Vidya Balan is amazing in Amit Masurkar’s ambitious Newton follow-up
Amit Masurkar walks into the woods and comes back with a good-to-great movie. That’s just how it works. On the way, he encounters radical-minded ruffians and bumbling ‘babus’. But a single scene in his films has more passion than the entire recent output of certain chiselled Bollywood heroes combined.
Like Masurkar’s breakout hit, Newton, his new film Sherni (out on Amazon Prime Video) is part satire of Indian bureaucracy and part understated call to action for conservationof animals, of nature, and most importantly, of our shared humanity.
Watch the Sherni trailer here:
Vidya Balan is uncharacteristically understated as the rookie Divisional Forest Officer (DFO) Vidya Vincent. She’s the no-nonsense type, going about her job with quiet efficiency, despite the reams of red-tape that she often finds herself tangled in. Not once does Balan’s break out her trademark guffaw; not once does the ‘sherni’ roar. This is a good thing.
Vidya Vincent is, however, somewhat of a Mary Sue — a little too unblemished, especially considering the muck that’s thrown at her. There is no problem that she cannot overcome by dishing out a calm talking-to. While her male colleagues are routinely harassed, and sometimes even physically manhandled, Vincent often gets her way by simply exuding confidence and trust — although even she, in her position of power, must deal with casual sexism on a daily basis.
Despite her qualifications, she’s an outsider, much like Ayushmann Khurrana’s Savarna saviour character in Article 15— a film with which Sherni shares several themes.
Vincent’s authoritative aura comes in handy in some of the more hairy situations that she finds herself in. The villagers are angry. A tigress is on the rampage, killing their brothers and sisters every few days. Under pressure from his bosses, Vincent’s own boss, a woefully inept man played by Brijendra Kala, hires a hunter. Played by the human tree trunk Sharat Saxena, Pintu the hunter is hardly as harmless as his name suggests. He claims that he can spot a man-eating tiger by simply staring in its eyes.
Vincent, meanwhile, puts together an ad-hoc team of her own, comprising of a couple of low-ranking officials, and a local zoology professor, played by a remarkably restrained Vijay Raaz. The professor tries to explain to the villagers that it is in the nature of the beast to fend for itself; the tigress isn’t inherently evil, it’s merely hungry. But the walls are closing in; public pressure is mounting, and two local ‘vidhayaks’ named PK and GK have politicised the matter. Vincent and Pintu’s squads put their opposing strategies into practice and prevent further death.
Although the satirical elements in Sherni aren’t as pronounced as they were in Newton, Masurkar’s eye for absurdity is as sharp as ever. In one scene, Kala’s character discusses killing the tigress over some chai and pakoras. Like so many mid-level managers, he thinks having even the sketchiest grasp of English somehow makes him superior. In another, rather on-the-nose moment, Masurkar frames the man in a manner that the hunting trophy mounted on the wall behind him appears to give him horns.
Sherni is a cleverly veiled allegory for modern India. Never is this more clear than in an early scene, when a street play about peace, love and understanding is interrupted by a local politician spouting violent rhetoric. Granted, he’s talking about tigers. But is he?
What stands out in both Newton and Sherni is that there are processes in place — elaborate, carefully crafted processes put together by intelligent people — but they’ve been systematically uprooted by privilege, patriarchy and prejudice.
Sherni has a lot on its mind. Many might be expecting it to unleash a rebellious rallying cry, and there’s a real possibility that they are taken aback by the film’s relaxed pace. Others might be anticipating a stirring takedown of sexism — especially because of Balan’s casting in the central role — but Sherni addresses this theme in the most matter-of-fact manner, much like Vidya Vincent herself. The film’s ambitions are, instead, loftier. It would be presumptuous to call it ahead of its time, but Sherni’s true relevance will only be felt when our rivers dry out and our coasts are submerged. So maybe a decade?
Director – Amit Masurkar
Cast – Vidya Balan, Vijay Raaz, Brijendra Kala, Sharat Saxena, Neeraj Kabi
The author tweets @RohanNaahar
Milestone movie review: Ivan Ayr’s Netflix film captures the mood of a nation
The Disciple review: A demanding film by master-in-the-making Chaitanya Tamhane
Get our daily newsletter
Smriti Irani shares old clip of Steffi Graf getting marriage proposal on court
Bird lays eggs in nest built on wreath on a door, homeowner posts pics of babies
Captivating video of black butterflies mud puddling will amaze you. Watch
Amrita Rao reacts to ‘Cristiano Ronaldo made Jal lijiye meme international’ post